I belong to the school of thought, perhaps you can even call it a religion, that believes only Mariah can do Mariah. It is a known fact that it is suicidal to attempt a Mariah song, especially on shows like American Idol. Anyone, and I mean ANYONE, who attempts to sing her songs are bound to:
a) make complete fools of themselves, they’d wish they were dead.
b) die of depression, because no matter how well they sang Mariah’s songs, they would always be considered mediocre compared to her.
Thus, I was in a state of pure, unadulterated bliss and excitement when I heard about American Idol’s Mariah Week. For those who have read my previous blog, you’d know how totally stoked I was for today. And for those haters ( *cough* Justin *cough*) who keep on dissing about how this is all a publicity stunt for her new album, keep on hating. I’m sure Mariah cares. Nyahahaha!
Knowing that those poor, poor souls only have two options, to either fail miserably or be considered so-so, I was excited to see blood flow. However, I also had hopes that they wouldn’t butcher Mariah’s songs, or that some of my “favorites” would actually learn from her. As I wrote in my previous blog, some of the contestants should use this time to reinvent themselves, do something different, shock people (in a good way.) Admittedly, 90% of Mariah’s songs are flirty, fun, sexy. After MJ and the stripper boi got booted off, A.I. was totally dull. This should have been a fun week. But as the title of this blog suggests, this week was a TOTAL FAILURE. Why? Reader, be cautioned. There are some serious spoilers ahead, and a lot of HATE. Read on at your own risk.
*****
Let’s start with David Archuleta. This boy has got an amazing voice. That’s a fact. He’s also cute, young, and attractive. I’m sure, despite his age, you’ve all thought how he was in bed. I’m kidding, maybe that was just me. :p LOL. Anyway, as I said, we know David A. is bankable. His appeal is almost universal. Young kids luvvv him, Mommas just wanna pinch his cheeks, and more! HOWEVER, he keeps on singing LAME songs!
Seriously, I am so over him. This week he sang “When You Believe” from the “Prince of Egypt” soundtrack. Groundbreaking, David. Totally brave song to do. Oh, but wait, doesn’t this sound like all the songs you’ve sang before? Isn’t this another one of those inspirtational-i’ll-save-the-world-i’m-here-for-you songs? RIGHT. What the f*ck is new with that? He didn’t even sing it with the same jaw-dropping, tear-inducing quality as he did “Imagine.” If you are going to sing something like this, Little David, make sure to wow people because if you don’t, they are just going to forget you. Or you’ll be known ALWAYS as the Ballad boy, sexless and unexciting. You don’t want that. BUT I really don’t care now. If you sang something up tempo, something cute, fun, or even a bit sexy, I would still be supporting you. You could’ve sang “My All” or acted all cute and boyish while singing “It’s Like That” and I’m sure all the girls in America would be voting for you. Stupid, stupid decision.
*****
Carly sang “Without You.” Infamous for being parodied so many times, but still a great, emotional song. I thought she started pretty well, she sounded in control. Her voice was made for these kinds of songs. The song choice was right for her, too. I would’ve wanted something lighter for her, but “Without You” is a powerhouse song. I thought Carly would’ve managed the high notes. However, it sounded like she was holding back at the end. She began to lose momentum, and I think the notes should have been one step higher. She could have really gained a lot if she was able to hit that last note. I mean, who hasn’t tried singing the part when you shout, “I Can’t live, if living is without you” thing, and find themselves almost injuring their throats? I thought Carly would manage it, after I heard her sing Heart. It was a bit disappointing, and scary, too. I LOVE Carly. I’m scared of her being eliminated. She’s got to be aware how good she really is. Wake up, bb. I don’t want you to go. :c
****
Syesha Mercado was good. I don’t particularly like her, and I think she’s one of those contestants you’d totally forget once they get booted off. I had no idea Mariah had a song named “Vanishing.” Still, I thought it was one of the best performances of the night. She did well. I loved the end where she played with the notes and that trilling part she did was awesome. I would have to search for the original to see how different/similar Syesha’s version is. She’s still not my favorite though, and I won’t be too sad if she left. Hopefully, she does before Carly. :c But tonight, I don’t think that’s possible. Syesha is clearly safe.
****
Brooke was a mess with “Hero.” UGH. The song would have been perfect for her. But she sounded like she was in a rush! She botched some keys, and a lot of notes were VERY flat. I have never been more aware of her breathing. I could hear it after every word! Seriously, I was thinking, “Was she a phone sex operator before? Because all this heavy breathing isn’t normal!” It was the most terrible performance of the night, IMHO. So I won’t be surprised if she gets booted off. I kinda like Brooke. She’s quirky, and she looks like a nice person, someone you can actually be friends with. I would be sad if she left, but after what she did with “Hero” tonight, I think there’s no saving her.
****
Jason Castro. My loverboi. :p Bb was also good. He sang another unknown song (well, I haven’t heard it before) “I Don’t Wanna Cry.” He made it sound his own, bluesy/reggaeish. Perfect song choice, IMO. Although, I would still have loved to hear something new from him. But overall, I think he did a good job. He won’t be going home, not yet.
****
I’m saving the best and the most surprising for last. I hate both of these guys for very different reasons. I hate Kristy Lee because Rami got booted off when she should have gone. She’s had really, really terrible songs, but still managed to survive. She’s like a f*cking cat! I hate David Cook because he’s too… generic rocker, imma shout all these notes guy. However, I found myself LOVING their performances tonight which is totally surprising for me.
I was shocked at how good Kristy Lee was with her rendition of “Forever.” It was countryish, yes, but it didn’t lose the Mariah flavor, and she played with it. The arrangement was awesome. She had perfect timing, and her voice was in top form. I loved it.
David Cook, IMHO (in my honest opinion), was the bravest tonight. He was the only one who sang a light song, something that wasn’t so melodramatic, so overdone, so serious! And I think it paid off. He sang “Always Be My Baby.” It was flat at some points, but I think it was a good, if not the best, choice. He didn’t shout a lot. It was lighter compared to the songs he’s been singing. And I loved the arrangement done on it, too. I shouldn’t say this, but I think he’s got a good chance to be in the Top 3. Argh.
*******************
ALL in ALL, it was a dismal Mariah Week, with only a few bright spots. I was hoping to hear someone sing something new, such as “We Belong Together” or even “Touch My Body”! It would have been soooo awesome to see Carly do something fun and light and flirty. To see David A. let loose and act his age. To see country gals Brooke and Kristy act all thug and hiphop. I am pretty much underwelmed by the whole thing. I’m happy though, that some managed to make it through with their dignity intact. I’m happy that it probably won’t be Carly or JC who will go home tomorrow.
Someone won’t be blogging about American Idol anymore.
Posted in Uncategorized